There are some films where it's impossible to go in with a completely open mind. Whether it's because it's a sequel to a film you've seen a hundred times, it's the work of a director or actor you're very familiar with or you've been bombarded with a relentless marketing campaign, there are many factors that can influence your opinion of a film before you go and see it. And, of course, there's the title. The one inescapable truth about this film is that it's called Return of the Killer Tomatoes, and is therefore not going to be anything even close to highbrow or arthouse, and might just about scrape the underbelly of being entertaining.
Now, unlike the last no-budget comedy-horror flick featuring George Clooney and starting with the word 'Return,' this one is actually a sequel, to 1978's Attack of the Killer Tomatoes, which I'm fairly sure doesn't star anyone of note, so I've no intention of ever watching it. The 4.4/10 rating on IMDb doesn't help either. Without doing any extra research (I'm on a deadline here, I need to go to sleep in an hour) I can tell from Return, in which they recap most of the plot and actually make a point of a viewer complaining about them recaping the original plot, that there was some kind of mysterious science plot in which monster tomatoes were created and vanquished using music. Something similar takes place in Return, but here the scientist (John Astin, I knew I recognised him, only just realised it's from The Addams Family), Dr. Putrid T. Gangreen, is creating tomatoes that take on human form, any form, and he plans to take over the world by creating a tomato version of the president.
Since the first film's plot, a whole new generation has grown up without knowing the glories of tomatoes, as they were outlawed by the government. There is a fairly healthy tomato racket on the black (or red) market, but the pizzeria in which our hero Chad Finletter (Anthony Starke) works makes pizzas by substituting the tomato sauce with raspberry jam or boysenberry, and accompany it with toppings ranging from gummy bears and peanut butter to something called the famous deep fried fish pizza, which sounds disgusting. Chad works as the delivery boy, and has the hots for Tara, the beautiful assistant/lover of Dr. Gangreen, but has never really been able to strike up the courage to talk to her. Also, she's a tomato. That's pretty clear from the start, seeing as she's been created as the 'perfect woman' in every respect, apart from she hates music and bathes in fertiliser. Chad's uncle Wilbur (J. Stephen Peace) owns the pizzeria (he's the hero of the first film), and Chad's room mate Matt (George Clooney) works there too, inbetween scams to have sex with every woman he comes across.
In case you haven't guessed, this film is pretty ridiculous. The plot is insane, the production value is non-existent and the acting equally scarce. There's a creature called F. T. (which stands for either Furry Tomato or Freak Tomato) who is quite clearly a cuddly toy being wiggled by a stick or strings. But this all adds to the home-made feel, and in fact attention is brought to how terrible the film is by more meta than I can really handle. The film even begins by being shown in someone's lounge (they initially start showing a film called Big Breasted Girls Go To The Beach And Take Their Tops Off, but thankfully this is stopped early on), and there are phone calls from viewers peppered through the film, and halfway through the camera pans out to find the director telling everyone they have to stop filming because they've run out of money. Ridiculously, there's two more films in the Killer Tomatoes franchise; Killer Tomatoes Strike Back and Killer Tomatoes Eat France, both also directed by John de Bello and who appears as himself in at least Return, but I can safely say I won't be seeing either of those films ever.
There were quite a few moments in the film that I can recommend though. Gangreen assistant, Igor (Steve Lundquist) is an aspiring news anchor who keeps on turning to the screen and saying things like "We'll be right back, after this..." which I found to be consistently ridiculous enough to be entertaining, and the script contains such straight-faced gems as "I thought you were ketchup!" and "The girl of my dreams is a vegetable!" (at no point is the tomato correctly identified as a fruit). Some bits go a bit far into the stupid though - when Wilbur comes to the rescue, it's dressed as a paratrooper with a deployed parachute that drags along the ground, along with a man permanently dressed in scuba gear who communicates with title cards even over the phone, and a severely overweight man in a Lone Ranger costume.
It's a very immature film that I would have doubtlessly enjoyed 10-15 years ago, but I'm proud to say I'm now too mature for it (when sober, at least). On a drunken Friday night with a group of mates it might be worth a punt, but seeing as I watched it at 7:00 am on Saturday morning it didn't really hit the spot.
Choose life 4/10